Witness Testimony
Mr. Richard Tindal
Vice President, Internet Registry Services NeuStar, Inc. 2000 M Street, N.W.
Suite 600
Washington, DC, 20036
The 'Dot Kids' Internet Domain: Protecting Children Online
Subcommittee on Telecommunications and the Internet
May 6, 2004
09:30 AM
Summary
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Shimkus, Mr. Markey and distinguished Members of the
Committee. I am Richard Tindal, Vice President, Registry Services for
NeuStar, Inc. ("NeuStar"). I appreciate the opportunity to appear
before you today to discuss NeuStar's implementation of the Dot Kids
Implementation and Efficiency Act of 2002 (the "Dot Kids Act").
NeuStar is very proud of its achievements in helping to carry out the objectives
of the Dot Kids Act. The Dot Kids domain is up and running today with over
1700 names registered and thirteen live sites available for use.
We believe that kids.us is an important public resource for
America
's children and express our appreciation for the leadership and dedication
this Committee has shown in creating this domain and at every stage, in
supporting our efforts to make kids.us a reality for our Nation's children.
NeuStar is committed to making kids.us a success and we look forward to
continuing to work with you to accomplish the important objectives of the Dot
Kids Act.
I will begin my testimony by providing background on NeuStar and the steps
taken prior to and since enactment of the Dot Kids Act to carry out the
objectives and requirements of the law. This effort involved the
work of employees from all across NeuStar and resulted in a flawless launch of
the kids.us domain three months prior to the statutory deadline. I will
then discuss the status of the domain and review NeuStar's 2004 marketing
program for kids.us.
Background
Since its founding,
NeuStar, a privately held technology and registry company, has established
itself as the premier trusted neutral third party provider of mission critical
infrastructure services and has developed lines of business serving both the
telecommunications and Internet industries. NeuStar operates the official
directory for all North American telephone numbers and manages the database
carriers rely on to rate and route billions of telephone calls each day.
NeuStar also operates a state of the art Internet registry managing all names in
the "Dot-US" top level domain, and with its joint venture partner, Melbourne
IT, Ltd., the names in the "Dot-BIZ" top-level domain. In addition,
NeuStar 's registry handles the routing needs of data services such as
Multimedia Messaging Services. Finally, NeuStar is a leading provider of
Operations Support Services clearinghouse services that allow telecommunications
and enterprise firms to automate and increase the efficiency of ordering,
service provisioning and billing and customer service functions.
Overview of the kids.us Pre-Launch Policy, Operational, Technical, and
Outreach Accomplishments
The question of how we as a society can protect children on the Internet is
an important and challenging one for all of us. There are numerous tools
available today including browser filters, educational campaigns, and rating
systems. Each of these options contributes something important and
valuable to attaining the goal of Internet safety for children. Kids.us
provides another important tool for
America
's children. NeuStar remains committed to the success of kids.us and
will continue to manage the domain and advance the goals laid out by Congress.
Policy Accomplishments
NeuStar's first task, which commenced eight months before enactment of the
Dot Kids Act, was to define the policies and procedures that would govern the
kids.us domain. NeuStar conducted a public outreach effort, consulting
with several child advocacy groups and other organizations to develop the
guidelines for determining what material would be deemed unacceptable for and/or
harmful to minors. The resulting content policy identifies and defines
thirteen categories of content that are restricted from kids.us. [1]
Next, NeuStar drafted the kids.us Takedown Procedures. These procedures
define the process for enforcement of the kids.us Content Policy in a way that
is transparent, fair and expeditious for the registrants.
Additionally, all Dot-US policies are applicable and enforced in the kids.us
domain. This includes the US Nexus Requirement, usTLD Dispute Resolution
Policy, and requirements for accurate Whois data. Finally, to implement
these new policies, NeuStar modified the Dot-US Registrar Accreditation and
Registry-Registrar Agreements to include the policies and procedures governing
the registration of kids.us domain names.
Operational Model and Accomplishments
The next step in developing the framework for kids.us was to determine how
the registration and content review process[2]
would work, consistent with the Dot Kids Act. We relied on our experience
implementing Dot-Biz and Dot-US by developing a model that would both protect
and preserve the requirements of the Dot Kids Act while providing as much
clarity as possible to potential registrants.
When determining how best to ensure the integrity of the kids.us domain and
to manage the content review and enforcement processes, NeuStar concluded that
it should directly oversee and manage the content review process. We did
this because we knew it would be important that content review be handled in a
neutral fashion, that is, for content review to be centrally and consistently
administered for all registrants. Content review includes several discrete
functions: developing and maintaining a customer interface to purchase
content subscriptions, the review of all content within the domain, enforcement
of the kids.us Content Policy, and customer account management.
To ensure a competitive registration process, NeuStar maintained the existing
registry-registrar model whereby only accredited registrars sell kids.us domain
names to the public. As a result, establishing a web presence within kids.us is
a 2-step process for any interested content provider: (1) registration of
a domain name with a registrar, and (2) purchase of a content review
subscription from NeuStar. NeuStar has engaged the support of a
subcontractor, Kidsnet, Inc., to assist us in the review function, with both the
initial and ongoing reviews of all active content. This review function
utilizes both manual reviews as well as a "spidering," filter technology.
Technical Accomplishments
With the operational model defined, NeuStar's technical staff made the
modifications to the Dot-US registry necessary to accommodate new registrations
at the third level. This technical effort involved the development of new
technical services and support mechanisms needed to launch kids.us. These
technical modifications included:
-
Modifying the source code of the Dot-US registry to accept third-level kids.us
registrations;
-
Modifying the source code of Whois to include kids.us registrant contact data;
-
Creating the content management system, and;
-
Launching the end-user directory.
The kids.us namespace is administered from a highly reliable infrastructure,
offering near real-time registrations and name server updates.
Pre-launch Outreach Accomplishments
Prior to the launch of the kids.us domain, NeuStar conducted an outreach
program to raise awareness of kids.us, encourage participation from registrars,
and drive public adoption of the new domain. We were able to leverage our
existing relationships with the registrar community, the contacts we had made
through the development of the kids.us Content Policy, and media connections to
promote the space.
In summary, NeuStar's pre-launch outreach initiatives included:
-
Engaging in media outreach including issuing press releases, sending e-mail
messages to a broad range of users, contracting a PR firm to promote Sunrise
launch among trademark holders looking to protect their marks (the "Sunrise
Phase");
-
Creating marketing collateral and organizing sales meetings and informational
briefing sessions with registrars, and;
-
Contacting potential technology partners for browser and directory
functionality.
Launch, Enforcement, and Enhanced Services
Launch
The launch of kids.us was a technical and operational success and was
conducted in a 2-part process. On June 17, 2003, NeuStar initiated the
Sunrise Phase for trademark protection, enabling owners of existing or pending
United States
trademarks or service marks to apply for kids.us domain names that exactly
match their trademarks or service marks. To ensure the integrity of the
Sunrise Phase, NeuStar compared each of the domain name applications received
with trademarks applied for or registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark
Office on or before December 31, 2002.
On September 4, 2003 at noon E.S.T., NeuStar opened registrations to the
general public. At the close of the first hour, the registry had
successfully registered over 400 kids.us names. At the same time that open
registration began, NeuStar activated the content management system.
NeuStar flawlessly launched the kids.us domain three months prior to the date
required by the Dot Kids Act.
Review and Enforcement
The on-going enforcement of the kids.us domain involves reviewing all kids.us
content for compliance with the kids.us Content Policy, and then enforcing that
policy in accordance with the kids.us Takedown Procedures. In this initial
period following the launch NeuStar carried out all aspects of the content
review role. To date, NeuStar has had very positive experiences in the
process of content management and enforcement. The content received is
generally appropriate for the domain. In addition, any content violations
found have typically been inadvertent hyperlinks or a link to an e-mail box that
was missed in the registrant's efforts to make a site compliant with the
kids.us Content Policy. Details of the enforcement activity for the
first three months are available in the "Annual Compliance Report on the
kids.us Domain" filed with the Congress and the Department of Commerce on
December 4, 2003, pursuant to the requirements of the Dot Kids Act.
Enhanced Services
Although not a specific requirement of the Dot Kids Act, NeuStar introduced a
child-oriented end-user directory to facilitate use of the domain by both
children and adults. All active sites are listed in this directory and are
sorted based on the registrant's self-categorization of their content.
An additional feature at the kids.us homepage is a third-party reporting tool.
This tool - a user web-form- provides a direct mechanism to contact NeuStar
24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year to report an alleged content
violation within kids.us. This tool provides an additional element of
safety and strengthens our collective abilities to protect children while they
are online. In January, the kids.us homepage was redesigned and expanded
to include a public Whois lookup for interested registrants as well as for
parents to identify the owners of kids.us sites.
NeuStar kids.us Marketing Program for 2004
On June 1, 2004, NeuStar will re-introduce the kids.us domain to the
marketplace by implementing a multifaceted marketing campaign that includes
advertising, public relations, customer outreach and direct marketing programs.
This new program is designed to: (1) broaden consumer awareness and use of
the kids.us namespace; (2) encourage the activation of content by registrants;
and (3) increase the number of kids.us domain name registrations.
The kids.us marketing program will accomplish these goals by creating greater
awareness among potential registrants and consumers through direct and joint
marketing, reaching out to existing kids.us registrants to encourage content
development and activation, and energizing the registrar sales channel to
promote kids.us more actively.
Through direct and joint public relations activities and advertising, NeuStar
will work to expand awareness of the kids.us namespace and specifically
highlight sites already up and running with content, as well as those that
develop content while the program is ongoing. By increasing public and
corporate awareness of the kids.us opportunity, and offering financial
incentives to our registrar sales channel to help spread the word, we will
initiate a call-to-action for those domain holders that have not yet taken the
important step of developing content and becoming live participants in the
kids.us namespace.
The direct marketing component of NeuStar's plan includes: (1) banner
ad placement on line; (2) direct e-mail campaigns; (3) creative marketing
promotions to generate end-user interest and (4) direct mail campaigns to
existing registrants that have not yet turned up content.
NeuStar will offer the registrar sales channel financial incentives intended
to encourage registrars to approach those customers who have registered domains,
but not yet developed or turned up content and ensure their support in marketing
kids.us domain names. These incentives will include limited time revenue
sharing and a rebate program for new registrations and renewals that extend
registration terms of existing names.
These incentives are designed to help increase activation of kids.us content
and websites and increase awareness of registration opportunities in the kids.us
namespace. By creating incentives through our registrar channel and
working directly with companies that have already registered domains, NeuStar
hopes to encourage the activation of kids.us content. Finally, the focus of the
public relations component of the marketing plan will be to create general
awareness through press releases and advertising. The media outreach will
be directed to business press and publications that cover government and to
Internet trade publications, websites and industry newsletters.
Conclusion
NeuStar is committed to making kids.us a success and providing an important
service to children, parents, and educators throughout our nation. We take
a great deal of pride in developing and launching what we view to be an
important new public resource for
America
's children. Like most good things, however, success will not come
overnight for kids.us. NeuStar expects, consistent with the launch of
almost any new domain name service, kids.us will follow a normal market adoption
curve, that is, adoption will be low in the beginning and gradually increase
over time. Eventually, it will reach a point when the registration rate
increases and the space will become more visible. Increased visibility
will depend upon high-profile registrants using and promoting their kids.us
sites.
NeuStar's new marketing campaign is designed to increase awareness and
adoption and accelerate the market acceptance of the new kids.us domain.
NeuStar strongly believes kids.us will continue to mature and grow. We
fully express our continued commitment to this important public resource.
NeuStar has accomplished every task identified in the Dot Kids Act and in an
effort to enhance the domain, delivered more than was expressly required.
With the marketing program outlined here, NeuStar continues to demonstrate that
we are taking the steps needed to enhance and improve the kids.us domain.
We cannot, of course, do this alone and as noted at the start of this testimony,
we truly appreciate the leadership, interest, and attention provided by this
Committee and the Department of Commerce. We look forward to continuing
our work with you in this special role as the registry for kids.us.
[2]
Content includes all written, dynamic and visual material within a website,
including the domain name.
|